For fans of hit true crime podcast Anatomy of Murder, mystery is not unusual. As listeners of the genre, interest in criminal cases, unsolved questions, and victim's stories makes sleuthing something of a hobby. But they weren't expecting their favorite hosts, Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi and Scott Weinberger, to disappear one day, too.
Many of the show's fans took to social media forums like Reddit to voice their confusion. Several wondered why the feed had gone cold, and whether their contract had come to an end. Some users began shared their feelings about a show they adored and hadn't expected to end:
As a [criminal justice] professional, I love this podcast. They don’t sensationalize and when they give an opinion it’s coming from a place of education and experience, not “I could have been a detective.”
It wasn't until an article in Variety was published a few weeks later that fans began to piece together a clearer picture of the reasons the hosts left their chart-topping podcast. At the end of 2025, creators and hosts of AoM announced they were leaving former network Audiochuck under acrimonious circumstances. They decided to create their own project, something that they could truly own. That new show, which launched in late May 2026, is called Homicide 360.
The new show is much like their original formula. After all, victim-focused storytelling has always been at the heart of what Nicolazzi and Weinberger do. As hosts, they bring rare insider credentials to the genre: Nicolazzi spent 21 years at the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office, 16 of those as a member of its elite Homicide Bureau, where she specialized in complex cases and left as Chief of Trials, while Weinberger began his career as a deputy sheriff, then moved on to become an Emmy Award-winning investigative journalist whose career has been defined by unparalleled access to law enforcement. In 2024, he spent two years embedded inside a police department, contributing to the investigation that resolved a 40-year-old cold case murder.
In a recent conversation, the hosts of Homicide 360 shared their gratitude about the response from their fans. After reading through more than a thousand positive comments platforms like Apple Podcasts, Weinberger was moved by the messages of support. "It's pretty incredible, actually. It shows you how much people really care about [our mission]."
For Weinberger and Nicolazzi, it has always been about telling crime stories in a way that honors the victims. In an upcoming episode, dropping on October 6, 2026, the show will cover the tragic story of a spousal abuse victim to honor Domestic Violence Awareness Month in October. For the duo, it is important to get the episode right. "We interviewed the prosecutor who worked with the victim when she was alive, and who watched the tragic escalation of her case, and also the prosecutor who then handled the homicide case," Nicolazzi exclusively shared. “They shared a lot of their training and insight which can benefit us all to hear.”
Rather than feel deflated by their difficult journey, the hosts of Homicide 360 feel reinvigorated. "We need to spread the word to our fans that we're back," Weinberger declared with a smile.
Luckily, more and more are finding the new show every day, whether through their social media account or on the same forums that first noticed their disappearance. It looks like this "mystery" will soon be solved for good.
