Skip to content

Thank you for supporting our publication. Some content contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission.

Genius Bimbos Ad Banner - Header

Apple's Heart Has No Pulse

Lacking curiosity and packed with mindless repetition, Heart feels so pointless that the story borders on parody. Is there anything redeeming here?

Apple's Heart Has No Pulse | Podcast Review
Published:

Heart begins with an astonishing premise. Terry dies by suicide. His heart is transplanted into the ailing Sonny. But a heart isn’t the only thing the two men have in common. Years after recovering from the operation, Sonny meets Terry’s wife Cheryl, and he leaves his own wife of 38 years to be with her. Eventually, Sonny will also die by suicide. Apple’s Heart, narrated by Karen Kilgariff of My Favorite Murder fame, digs into the astounding story. 

There are two threads to Heart. The first is an exploration of the concept of "cellular memory," the theory that all that makes us us does not reside just in our brains, but in our bodies, too. Specifically, our hearts.

The second thread, a true crime narrative that posits wife Cheryl as the reason both men died, is what the podcast is most interested in. Did their shared wives, rather than their shared hearts, have more to do with their deaths – or is it merely another coincidence? 

These suspicions are largely emotional, rather than grounded in evidence. The majority of voices we hear on Heart belong to the friends and family of Terry and Sonny, and although many of them are adamant their loved one would not have died by suicide, few imply Cheryl actually pulled the trigger. And as we hear in one of the many, many disclaimers, she has not been found guilty of anything. Her treatment of her two husbands, along with her behavior in general, is what goes under the microscope. 

As we hear in the legalistic spiel that ends every episode, Cheryl declined to be interviewed for the podcast. While that does present a predicament, there appears to have been little effort to reach out to any of her friends or neutral parties, leaving Heart feeling one-sided. Almost everything you hear on the show makes Cheryl seem like a terrible person. She may well be. Yet, she is also a person who became the way she is due a confluence of events and factors that might have been worth exploring in more than scant detail. That lack of curiosity leaves a real hollowness at the core of the show. 

Each episode is packed to the rafters with disclaimers; of the legal variety in regards to Cheryl’s culpability, but also about how the theory that our heart could retain come of our essence after death is not widely accepted in the medical community. Though that acknowledgement of the dubious science is welcome in some respects (if you’ve heard The Telepathy Tapes, you know that disclosures are not guaranteed), that these caveats are reiterated so very often makes you wonder the point of raising the theories in the first place. 

Then there are the contributions from the loved ones of Terry and Sonny, which, for the most part, constitute a litany of examples of every time Cheryl so much as looked at someone funny, and a sentiment summed up neatly by Terry’s sister Tammy recounting Cheryl’s reaction to his death, “She didn’t react the way I think she should have reacted.” Admittedly, some of her actions were quite suspicious, but because of those aforementioned disclaimers, we know no great surprise is coming.

Arguably, an even bigger problem is Heart’s confounding amount of repetition. The show lays out the main beats of the story in the first episode, and in the following instalments zooms in closer on certain events. For every piece of new information, there are three things we’ve heard before. 

One episode is so similar to the next that sometimes it feels like the whole thing is just a single episode, reshuffled over and over again. That incessant repetition is even evident on a sentence-by-sentence basis. Take this passage about the morning of Sonny’s suicide:

“It begins just like any other day, and that’s where the questions start. Michelle’s questions, Gray’s questions, Lauren’s questions. Because it all seems so normal. The rhythm of life, today, this morning, it beats just like any other, a regular rhythm. The pulse seems normal, unremarkable.”

It borders on the parodic, and all leaves the impression of someone having a quota of time to fill and nowhere near the amount of material to fill it, so desperately resorting to some verbal vamping. This happens throughout the entire show, with never one adjective being used when three were available, and information reiterated so often that it’s almost patronizing. If it wasn’t for Karen Kilgariff’s pleasingly musical narration, large portions would be downright hard to listen to. 

And so while Heart does indeed have an astonishing premise, its absolute refusal to expand beyond that conceit in any meaningful way is ultimately the most noteworthy thing about it.

Chloe Walker

Chloe Walker

Chloe is a writer based in the UK. You can find more of her work at the BFI, Paste, The A.V Club, Culturefly, Crooked Marquee, Little White Lies, and various other websites.

All articles

More in Reviews

See all

More from Chloe Walker

See all

From our partners

Genius Bimbos Ad Banner - Footer